Skip to content

Common well pressure tank problems

What short cycling, spitting faucets and a waterlogged tank usually mean — and which checks are safe for a homeowner.

General guidance, not specific to any model · reviewed 2026-11-10

Well pumps run on high-voltage circuits and the system is under pressure. Switch off the pump's breaker and relieve pressure before touching fittings, and never open the pressure switch cover.

What the pressure tank does

A well pressure tank stores a reserve of water under pressure, so the pump doesn't have to start every time you open a tap. Most modern tanks have a bladder or diaphragm with a cushion of air on one side, set to a “pre-charge” pressure. The pressure switch turns the pump on at a lower pressure (cut-in) and off at a higher one (cut-out).

Signs something is wrong

  • Short cycling: the pump clicks on and off every few seconds while water is running. This is the classic sign of a tank that has lost its air charge (“waterlogged”), or a pre-charge that's set wrong.
  • Pressure that swings quickly between high and low at the tap.
  • Water coming out of the air valve on top of the tank when you briefly press its pin — on a bladder tank this usually means the bladder has failed.
  • The tank sounds solid (full of water) when tapped all the way to the top, rather than hollow near the top.
  • The pump cycling when no water is being used, which points elsewhere — often a leak, a running toilet, or a problem in the well piping or check valve.

Safe things you can observe

  • Read the pressure gauge as the pump turns on and off, and note both numbers.
  • Time how long the pump runs and how long it rests while a tap is open.
  • Check fixtures and toilets for leaks if the pump runs with no water in use.
  • Look for rust, sweating or drips on the tank and its fittings.

Checking the pre-charge

Pre-charge is checked with the pump switched off and the tank drained of water pressure, using a tire gauge on the air valve. The correct value depends on your pressure switch's cut-in setting — your tank's label and manual give the exact rule (for example, one major manufacturer says to set it 2 psi below the cut-in pressure). If you're not comfortable switching off the pump circuit and draining the system, this is a quick job for a well contractor.

When to call a professional

  • Any work on the pressure switch: it has exposed live terminals under its cover.
  • Replacing a tank, or a bladder that has failed.
  • Low or no pressure with the pump running, sputtering air, or sand in the water.
  • A breaker that trips when the pump starts.

Keep a record of your equipment

Track models, maintenance and repairs in one place — and get help that knows what you own.

Get started free